Books to Screen – The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

Books to Screen – The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly

Never judge a book by its movie. Today I want to talk about books going to the big (or little) screen. I’m actually going to be starting a new feature that is probably entirely unoriginal, but that’s okay. Basically I’ll be comparing a book to it’s movie (or tv show) and my thoughts on both and how the movie/tv show lived up (or not) to its book. The very first post for that feature will be going up on Thursday, so I thought this would be a good way to kick that off.

Whenever I hear that a book I’ve read will be hitting theaters or be made into a tv show, my initial reaction is a bout of squealing. I get super excited because I get to see that book come to life!

I mean, sure if it’s a great book it sort of does come to life in your imagination. But even so, it’s a nice thought to see your imagination come to life.

But that’s not always the case, is it?

Movies and TV shows based on books can sometimes be extremely disappointing. The entire story can be switched around and jumbled about, there might not be enough character and relationship building, or perhaps the characters don’t look anything like you pictured!

This has happened time and time again, yet usually we are all still excited to see if the next book-to movie will be the next Harry Potter.

Of course, it all depends on budget, who’s writing the screen play, and I think also it depends a lot on how involved the author is allowed to be. Most times authors have about as much say in how the movie turns out as we do (a.k.a. none). Which is a bit disappointing. Of course, the movies aren’t being made just for us book fans. They’re being made for people who haven’t read the books as well. But I think we all sort of wish that the big movie-making people would one day understand that the books are popular because of the way the story was told already. So why mess with a good thing?

Unfortunately that’s not something any of us can really change, so let’s talk about some of the goodies and the badies.

Let’s just get this out of the way though. I haven’t read all the Harry Potter books. *collective gasp* I know. I know I need to. I’ve only read the first one and honestly I didn’t love it like everyone else did. I truly blame it on the fact that I’ve already seen all the movies and I tend to draw visuals based on the movies as opposed to creating my own — so it’s not as fun. But obviously there’s nothing I can do about that. I do plan on finishing the series, but I just haven’t gotten around to it yet.

Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings Book to MovieNow that that’s out of the way, I think it’s pretty fair to say that the top movies that lived up to (or perhaps even surpassed) the books were the Harry Potter movies and the Lord of the Rings movies. I think most will agree that those two adaptions did their books the most justice. Of course, there’s probably a few obscure movies from books out there that I’m missing. But those two are by far the most popular and definitely all-around crowd-pleasers.

But what it is about these two sagas that got it right?

I think it’s a combination of a lot of things. I think the primary thing you’ll notice is that they both did not skimp on budget or movie length. They let the books come to life and however long they ended up being was how long they were. Obviously budget is something that cannot always happen. But movie length perhaps is.

I think filmmakers honestly underestimate the time in which a person is willing to sit down and watch a movie — especially if it’s a good one. Yes, an intermission would be nice (or perhaps a two-parter), but a long movie is probably the closest thing you can get to diving into a book. Details aren’t skimped on that draw us into the story and the characters — and this alone can make a world of difference.

So I think if perhaps every movie that made it to the big screen had a pretty healthy budget and if the length of the movie wasn’t worried about so much, then maybe more books to movies would turn out phenomenal.

As far as books to tv goes. I can’t say too much because, although I do intend to jump on the True Blood, Game of Thrones, and Vampire Diaries bandwagons, I haven’t yet. So I don’t really know how they live up. I have heard from many people that the True Blood tv show is in some ways better than the Sookie books. I’ve only read the first Sookie book, but didn’t love it. I do plan on trying more of the books, but I definitely intend on watching the tv show for sure — I just haven’t yet. But for those out there are are books-to-tv buffs, please feel free to put your input in. I would love to hear your thoughts!

Now let’s talk about the ugly for a little bit.

I’m not going to get too much into this because this post isn’t here to offend. But the most prominent book-to-movie in my mind that was incredibly disappointing is I’m sure one that a lot of you agree with. One that involves a certain sparkly vampire.

But I’ll say no more on that matter. Let’s talk more about the why of a book-to-movie not turning out so hot.

I think a lot of factors can play a role in this one. It’s hard to say what the biggest factor is. But the first thing I will say is that even if the actor/actress looks the part, that doesn’t mean they can play the part. Bad acting can take any movie and stomp it into the ground. Although I love it when they get people to play the roles that I think look pretty close to how I picture them in the book, I think it’s more important to get people who can do the part justice. Hair can be died, contacts can be put in. If they look even remotely the right age of the character, then everything else can be modified to a certain degree. But for heaven’s sake, get people who can actually act first and foremost.

Secondly, I think how the screenplay is written is another big factor. If the author is allowed to put their input into the screenplay, then all the better. But either way, if the screenplay writer doesn’t stay true to the book but adds things, subtracts things, and changes things, then eventually the original story starts to get lost. Take this certain sparkly vampire movie for example. The relationship between the main characters in the movie was non-existent and when “you are everything to me” is said after what seemed like two days, it leaves a lot of “huh” expressions on people’s faces. For those of us who read the book and know how many other things (off screen) happened before that statement, it makes a hell of a lot more sense.

So there’s my two cents on the matter. Books-to-screen can go either way and really there’s really no telling until we see the movie/tv show for ourselves. There’s a certain movie about particular set of deadly games that I can tell you I am definitely looking forward to coming out in March. Hopefully it doesn’t disappoint, but of course, it very well could.

But what are your thoughts? What movies or tv shows do you think have done their book(s) the most justice? Which ones have been the worst for you?

  • You Slay Me by Katie MacAlister

    Aisling Grey is a courier enjoying a free, work-related trip to Paris when she learns she's a Guardian. That's a keeper of the Gates of Hell, for those who don't know. She finds this out from Drake Vireo, who's scrumptiously sexy-at least in his human form. Now Drake has stolen the package Aisling was sent to deliver, and she must track him down, get the package, and try to resist the passion boiling inside her.
  • Written in Red by Anne Bishop

    As a cassandra sangue, or blood prophet, Meg Corbyn can see the future when her skin is cut—a gift that feels more like a curse. Meg’s Controller keeps her enslaved so he can have full access to her visions. But when she escapes, the only safe place Meg can hide is at the Lakeside Courtyard—a business district operated by the Others. Shape-shifter Simon Wolfgard is reluctant to hire the stranger who inquires about the Human Liaison job. First, he senses she’s keeping a secret, and second, she doesn’t smell like human prey. Yet a stronger instinct propels him to give Meg the job. And when he learns the truth about Meg and that she’s wanted by the government, he’ll have to decide if she’s worth the fight between humans and the Others that will surely follow.
  • Wolfsbane by Andrea Cremer

    When Calla Tor wakes up in the lair of the Searchers, her sworn enemies, she’s certain her days are numbered. But then the Searchers make her an offer—one that gives her the chance to destroy her former masters and save the pack—and the man—she left behind. Is Ren worth the price of her freedom? And will Shay stand by her side no matter what? Now in control of her own destiny, Calla must decide which battles are worth fighting and how many trials true love can endure and still survive.
Load More Related Articles
  • Dani Harper

    Dani Harper  Jul 30 Review:Changeling Dream by Dani Harper Author: Dani HarperSeries: Changeling, #2Genre: Paranormal RomancePublisher: Brava (Imprint of Kensington)Date Published: ...
  • Christopher Pike

    Christopher Pike  Oct 28 Review:Thirst No.4:The Shadow of Death by Christopher Pike Author: Christopher PikeSeries: Thirst, #4Genres: Urban Fantasy, Young AdultPublisher: ...
  • Chloe Neill

    Chloe Neill  Jun 15 Review:Biting Cold by Chloe Neill Author: Chloe NeillSeries: Chicagoland Vampires, #6Genre: Urban FantasyPublisher: NAL (Imprint of Penguin)Date ...
Load More By Julie
  • Iron Fey

    Review: The Iron Queen by Julie Kagawa Author: Julie Kagawa Series: Iron Fey, #3 Publisher: Harlequin Date Published: January 25, 2011 ...
  • Kate Daniels

    Review: Magic Strikes by Ilona Andrews Author: Ilona Andrews Series: Kate Daniels, #3 Publisher: Ace Date Published: March 31, 2009 Genre(s): ...
  • Lords of the Underworld

    Review: The Darkest Secret by Gena Showalter Author: Gena Showalter Series: Lords of the Underworld, #7 Publisher: HQN Books Date Published: ...
Load More In Notes

Leave a Reply

Check Also

Dani Harper

Dani Harper  Jul 30 Review:Changeling Dream by Dani ...

Welcome to The YA Shelf

Helping you find the BEST young adult literature online! We're YA authors, readers and bibliophiles, who read everything and sometimes post book reviews and fandom summaries. Check out our "best books for teens" lists to see our favorites, or browse nearly 300+ book reviews!

Check out today's deals or See what's hot! Today's FREE books
Today's BestSellers


Top Posts & Pages

50 YA fiction tropes and cliches we can't get enough of!
The Best YA Fae Fantasy Books
The Best YA/Teen Fiction Books With Zombies
Sarah J Maas and YA cancel culture (what's up?)
The Best Time Travel Books for Teens
The YA shelf (young adult literature reviews)
The Best Greek Mythology Based Books for Teens
The Best Angel and Fallen Angel Romances for Teens


Category Posts

True Blue by Luanne Rice | I’m Loving ♥ Books

The Devil to Pay by Maria Zannini | I’m Loving ♥ Books



House of Night