I think everybody has a specific season of life they are constantly trying to recreate in fiction. For some people, it’s dark academia in autumn. For me, and for the millions of people who watch The Summer I Turned Pretty or read Emily Henry’s People We Meet on Vacation, it’s that specific, agonizingly slow burn of a summer romance that spans years of history.
It’s the “brother’s best friend” trope. It’s the “dating two brothers” love triangle. It’s the agonizingly long history of childhood vacations, inside jokes, and watching someone you’ve known forever suddenly look at you differently across a crowded beach bonfire.
Jenny Han perfected the angst of a teenage summer love triangle with Conrad and Jeremiah Fisher. Emily Henry perfected the adult version of two friends realizing they’ve been in love for a decade of summer trips. If you want that exact feeling of sun-drenched, history-laden romantic tension, here are the books you need.
Which one first? A quick comparison
| Book | Author | The setup | Pick it if you want |
|---|---|---|---|
| Every Summer After | Carley Fortune | Next-door summers on a lake in Ontario, told across six summers and the present day | The closest thing to The Summer I Turned Pretty written for adults |
| My Life Next Door | Huntley Fitzpatrick | Samantha watches the Garretts next door from her roof until Jase climbs up | YA boy-next-door magic with less angst than a love triangle |
| Closer (Audiobook) | My own project | Caught between two pulls, the safe brother and the darker one | Brother’s best friend tension, with the audio free on my YouTube channel |
| Love and Other Words | Christina Lauren | Then-and-now timeline: childhood sweethearts split by a betrayal, reunited as adults | Friends to lovers with a tragic misunderstanding |
| The Kissing Booth | Beth Reekles | Elle, her best friend Lee and his older brother Noah | The pure brother’s best friend trope, predictable and quick |
| Beach Read | Emily Henry | Two writers in neighboring beach houses for the summer | The summer setting with sharp, witty adult dialogue |
Reading for the adult version? Every Summer After is the one I would hand over first, and Beach Read brings the grown-up dialogue.
1. Every Summer After by Carley Fortune
If I had to hand someone a book and say “This is the closest thing to The Summer I Turned Pretty but written for adults,” it would be this.
Persephone and Sam grew up spending summers next door to each other on a lake in Ontario. They were best friends, then they were everything else, and then a catastrophic mistake ruined it all. The book jumps between the present day—when she returns to the lake for his mother’s funeral—and the six summers they spent growing up together.
It hits every single beat: the childhood nostalgia, the agonizing “will they won’t they,” the whole summer-house ache. It’s messy and emotional, and Carley Fortune is brilliant at making you feel the exact humidity of a lakeside summer.
2. My Life Next Door by Huntley Fitzpatrick
This is a classic YA summer romance that doesn’t get talked about enough anymore. Samantha Reed’s family is perfect and wealthy; the Garretts next door are loud, chaotic, and have eight kids.
Samantha sits on her roof watching them (a trope I will literally never get tired of) until Jase Garrett climbs up and says hello. It has that exact “boy next door” summer magic that makes you want to drive with the windows down. It’s less angsty than a love triangle, focusing more on the tension between her overbearing mother and his messy, wonderful family.
3. Closer (Audiobook)
This is one of my own projects, but if you’re specifically hunting for the “brother romance” or “brother’s best friend” dynamic, I wrote Closer to exist entirely in that space.
I wanted to take the deep, literary feeling of a slow-burn summer romance and inject it with the obsessive tension you find in bad-boy romances. It’s about being caught between two gravitational pulls—the safety of the brother you’re supposed to be with, and the darker, entirely inappropriate obsession with the other one. The audio version is up on my YouTube channel for free, and it leans heavily into that suffocating, humid tension of people who know each other too well to hide their worst impulses.
4. Love and Other Words by Christina Lauren
This book actually physically hurt my feelings. Similar to Every Summer After, this is a dual-timeline story told in “then” and “now.”
Macy and Elliot spent their teenage weekends reading books in a closet together. (It sounds weird; it’s actually incredibly intimate and lovely in the book). They were childhood sweethearts until a massive betrayal fractured them for a decade. When they run into each other at a coffee shop as adults, the entire history of their relationship comes crashing back. Christina Lauren (which is actually a writing duo) are absolute masters of the “friends to lovers with a tragic misunderstanding” trope.
5. The Kissing Booth by Beth Reekles
We have to talk about the Wattpad-to-movie pipeline again. If you want the pure, unfiltered “brother’s best friend” trope, this is the blueprint that launched a million Netflix subscriptions.
Elle is best friends with Lee. Lee’s older brother is Noah, the school’s resident bad boy who rides a motorcycle and gets into fights. Elle has had a crush on him forever. They set up a kissing booth for a carnival. You know exactly what happens next. It is not high art. It is not trying to be high art. It is the literary equivalent of a perfect pop song—predictable, catchy, and you will consume the entire thing in an afternoon without realizing it.
If the bad-boy angle is the reason you picked this one, our bad boy next door romance picks go further.
6. Beach Read by Emily Henry
Yes, People We Meet on Vacation is technically the “friends to lovers summer trip” book, but I actually think Beach Read has more of the specific tension people are looking for.
January is a romance writer who doesn’t believe in love anymore; Augustus is a literary fiction writer who thinks romance is a joke. They end up in neighboring beach houses for the summer, making a bet to write each other’s genre. It has the same DNA as a Jenny Han novel—the proximity, the summer setting, the slow unraveling of assumptions—but with the sharp, witty dialogue of adults who have been battered by life a little bit.
The appeal of these books is always the history. It’s not just about meeting someone and falling in love; it’s about realizing that the person you’ve known for ten years, the person who saw you with braces, the person who knows your coffee order, is suddenly the only person you want to look at.
Want more YA romance after these six? Our YA romance list is next.



















Leave a Reply