A plain dystopia warns you about us. A fantasy dystopia gives the regime something to fear: a girl whose touch kills, a teenager whose abilities get her sent to a camp, a pilot whose power is exactly what the state is draining. That is why these books keep the stakes personal, and why they get lost on ordinary dystopian lists. Below are seven YA picks where the rigged society and the magic arrive together, with the honest catch for each.
If you only read one, make it Red Queen: Publishers Weekly places it in a dystopian world, and the powers are the point. For the purest powers-and-a-camp story, try The Darkest Minds. For the dangerous, touch-is-lethal romance, Shatter Me. The last three picks stretch the label, and I say so where they do. Everything here is researched from publisher pages, trade reviews and reader reactions.
My rule for the list: the society has to be oppressive by design, and the magic or powers have to be more than set dressing. Plenty of books straddle science fiction and fantasy, so I note where Kirkus or the publisher files them. If you want the version with no magic at all, the posts linked at the end cover that ground.
Taste of Vampire by D.S. Murphy
Taste of Vampire drops a human girl bred to serve into a kingdom ruled by vampires: she is chosen by an elite, must survive a deadly Trials competition, and plots to kill the tyrant king while falling for his icy prince son. The dystopia is the caste system and the Trials, and the fantasy is the vampires. It is book one of four in the Kingdom of Blood and Ash series, and the series is finished. Skip it if vampires are not your lane. Disclosure: this one is ours, from the site owner’s own pen name or imprint, so weigh it like any author recommending their own book.
Red Queen by Victoria Aveyard
Publishers Weekly describes the setup as a dystopian world where Red-blooded people are an impoverished underclass serving Silver-bloods, whose supernatural gifts keep them in power. Mare Barrow, 17, discovers she can summon lightning, which makes her the spark for the Scarlet Guard rebellion. HarperTeen published it on February 10, 2015, and the main series runs four novels. The weakness is familiarity: Publishers Weekly said the book shares several plot points and similarities with The Hunger Games, with preternatural powers swapped in for the survival skills, and Kirkus noted that revolution takes priority over romance. Skip it if you want romance up front or a structure you have never seen.
Shatter Me by Tahereh Mafi
Juliette is locked in an asylum by the Reestablishment, a militaristic regime that rose after an environmental catastrophe, because her touch is lethal. After months of isolation she is given a cellmate, Adam, who is immune to her touch and is a soldier under orders from Warner, a power-hungry 19-year-old, per Kirkus. HarperTeen published it on November 15, 2011. Here the power is the plot, and the book leans hard on metaphor. The weakness is documented: Kirkus called it a dystopic thriller that does not distinguish itself on a crowded shelf, found the ending flat and the world thin, said the heavy metaphor wears thin, and said Juliette stays a pawn in other people’s schemes despite her powers. The posts linked at the end cover the rest of the series.
The Darkest Minds by Alexandra Bracken
Ruby is 16, has newly understood powers, and escapes a “rehabilitation camp” where she was imprisoned, then joins fellow escapees searching for the Slip Kid, a leader who shelters endangered young people and knows how to control one’s powers, per Wikipedia’s summary. Hyperion published it on December 18, 2012, and Kirkus filed it as a dystopian thriller for readers 14 and up. It is a four-novel run that ended with The Darkest Legacy in 2018, with novellas and short stories in between, and a film adaptation followed in 2018. The weakness: reception was not unanimous. Wikipedia reports positive reviews from Booklist, Publishers Weekly and Kirkus, but a mediocre one from The Guardian. With that many side stories, stick to the four novels first.
Skyhunter by Marie Lu
Talin is a Basean refugee in the country of Mara who faces xenophobic treatment but is respected for her fighting skill. Her group captures a former Federation fighter with unusual abilities, who tells them about the Federation’s genetically engineered, zombielike army of Ghosts, and they plan to sabotage Ghost production despite orders not to, per Kirkus. Roaring Brook Press published it on September 29, 2020, and Kirkus files it as fantasy with Dystopian Fiction among its categories. Macmillan’s series page is titled the Skyhunter Duology, with Steelstriker as the second book. It reads like a war story with a dystopian machine at the far end. The weakness: Kirkus liked the plotting and the quick battle scenes but found some of Talin’s realizations about her own motives a little too neat.
The Belles by Dhonielle Clayton
On their joint 16th birthday, Camellia and her five sisters are sent to restore beauty to Orléans, a world where everyone is born gray and ugly. The Belles use magic to transform citizens for a price, Camellia becomes the queen’s favorite, and the princess’s relentless pursuit of beauty becomes the central threat, per Kirkus. Freeform published The Belles on February 6, 2018. Kirkus’s verdict was Get it, calling it a fantasy and the first in a duology, and praising how it peels back the glamour to reveal something darker. Calling it a dystopia is my label, not Kirkus’s: the magic is a service sold for a price, and the court controls who gets it. The weakness: the threat is a palace and a princess, not an army, so skip it if you want battles.
Iron Widow by Xiran Jay Zhao
In Huaxia, a Chinese-influenced futuristic society, humans fight giant buglike aliens called Hunduns with war machines shaped like mythical animals. Each machine needs a male and a female pilot, and the female pilot usually dies from the drain on her qi. After her older sister dies this way, Zetian volunteers as a concubine-pilot to take revenge, per Kirkus. Penguin Teen published Iron Widow on September 21, 2021. It sits at the science-fiction end of the fantasy dystopian shelf, with myth and qi in place of spells, so treat it as the stretch pick. The weakness: Kirkus enjoyed it but found lapses in worldbuilding and in the characters’ relationships that make some events feel random and forced, and the review carries a content note whose details I could not see.
Where to start
Start with Red Queen if you want the genre’s standard shape, The Darkest Minds if you want powers and a camp, and Shatter Me if you want the romance first. Move to Skyhunter for a war, The Belles for court intrigue, and Iron Widow if you are happy for the label to bend. Taste of Vampire is the pick if you want vampires, the rigged Trials and a finished series in one go.
Questions readers ask
What makes a dystopian book fantasy?
For this list, the question is whether magic or powers drive the plot rather than decorate it. Kirkus files Legend under science fiction and The Belles under fantasy, and where the line blurs, as with Skyhunter and Iron Widow, I say so in the entry.
Is Legend a fantasy dystopian?
No. Kirkus classifies Marie Lu’s Legend (Putnam, November 29, 2011) as science fiction: a future Los Angeles with plagues and class warfare, where June, a privileged prodigy of the Republic, and Day, its most wanted criminal, are pushed into opposition. It is a fine pick if you want the dystopia half of the label without any magic, but it does not belong in the fantasy half.
Which one is closest to The Hunger Games?
Red Queen. Publishers Weekly says it shares several plot points and similarities with The Hunger Games, with preternatural powers swapped in for survival skills. That is a strength if you want the pattern again and a weakness if you want surprises.
Which of these are finished series?
As far as I could confirm, the Taste of Vampire series is complete at four books, Red Queen’s main series is four novels, The Darkest Minds novels ran through 2018, Skyhunter is a duology, and Kirkus calls The Belles the first in a duology. Kirkus says the Iron Widow epilogue sets up a sequel.
Want the version with no magic, or more of the same? Our books like Shatter Me list and the Shatter Me books in order guide follow the powers-and-regimes thread, while dark YA dystopian books and old-school YA dystopian books cover the plain dystopias.
Amazon links are affiliate links: we may earn a small commission at no cost to you.
Leave a Reply